May 18, 2018

Why Won't Family Help, and Why Do They Criticize Us?

The worst part of being a caregiver for a person living with dementia is that you seldom get much real help from family.

Why Won't Family Help, and Why Do They Criticize Us? | Alzheimer's Reading Room

By Donna StClair
Alzheimer's Reading Room

Time and again I have heard the same refrain:
the worst part of being a caregiver is that you seldom get much real help from family and close friends who should be able to pony up and provide just a smidgen of assistance.
I’ve got something worse than worst.

Instead of help and assistance, I get criticism.

Subscribe to the Alzheimer's Reading - This is a Free Service - Join Now

Have you ever heard these words?
  1. Why aren’t you doing this?
  2. How come you do that?
  3. You should take anti-depressants.
  4. Put him into day care somewhere--it’ll be better for him.
  5. He doesn’t seem so bad--why are you thinking of putting him anywhere.
  6. Why are you spending so much money?
  7. How come you don’t take time for yourself?

I’m not sure why it is so difficult for people to grasp this simple concept:

unless you have walked in the boots, you can’t comprehend the journey.

Consider how everyone is before they become parents.

Need Help? Search our Award Winning Alzheimer's Reading Room Knowledge Base for Answers to Your Questions, and Solutions to Problems

Having that first child is the greatest slice of humble pie that you will ever eat in your life. Almost everything you ever declare that your child will never do--he does. Almost everything you swear that you, as a parent, will never do--you do.

Little by little, you swallow every single prognostication that you ever uttered, until finally you wind up saying things like “As long as you live under my roof….”

Most people have experienced this humbling event.

So, why do these same people feel so well qualified to step forward and offer advice and criticism about a path that they have never walked--namely, that of an Alzheimer’s caregiver?

Did they learn nothing from the hearty slice of humble pie that they ate as new parents? Do they need a second serving, perhaps?

The recipe for being a loving and supportive family member or friend to an Alzheimer’s caregiver is such a simple one:
  • Listen when I talk. Don’t advise or critique. Just listen.
  • Ask, specifically, what you can do to help--not what I ought to do to help myself, but what YOU can do to help me. If I can’t think of anything, offer a suggestion or two based on what you have heard me say.
  • Deliver what you offer. If you have indicated your intention to spend quality time with your Alzheimer’s relative or friend, or to call regularly, or send cards and letters--do it, without being reminded. This clock is ticking ….

Don’t get me wrong: I crave suggestions and opinions from my fellow caregivers and from professionals who specialize in geriatrics or dementia.

I am all ears when these folks begin to talk. They know whereof they speak. I savor every word they have written. They are my oracles.

But for the rest of the world--if you can’t do something to help, at least refrain from hurting.

In other words ... help out ... or shut up.

Donna StClair is an Alzheimer's caregiver.

Related Articles

Are Alzheimer's Caregivers the Forgotten?

What is the Difference Between Alzheimer’s and Dementia

How to Test Your Memory for Alzheimer's and Dementia (5 Best Tests)

Communicating in Alzheimer's World

Learn More - Topics Pages

Dementia Care

Alzheimer's Communication is Important
"The Alzheimer's Reading Room is the one place on the Internet, and in the world, where those who are searching for information, encouragement and guidance can find the help they need from people who completely understand their questions and their journey".

Tom and Karen Brenner, Montessori Gerontologists, Brenner Pathways

You are reading original content the Alzheimer's Reading Room

Publisher Alzheimer's Reading Room
Author Donna StClair
May, 2017
Title: Why Won't Family Help, and Why Do They Criticize Us?